Value Differences

Some of us distrust God because we disagree with his moral values.

We endorse things he condemns. He draws distinctions we dispute. We elevate issues he considers secondary. He esteems that which we deem disposable.

Instead of aligning our moral values with God’s principles and precepts, we adjust our view of God and his moral code to accommodate our values.

Underlying Motivation

Moral disagreements with God usually stem from one of five root causes.

  • We lack understanding of what God says in the Bible. Instead, we rely on the incorrect interpretations concocted by those who are equally ignorant or on the rhetoric of those who actively oppose him.
  • We distrust God generally because he allows suffering to exist. We mistakenly believe he is indifferent to affliction and, therefore, untrustworthy, so we reject his moral values.
  • We are offended by judgmental believers who claim to speak for God. We mistakenly assume that he shares their obnoxious contempt, so we disdain his values.
  • We find the hypocrisy among reborn believers laughable. We rightly believe they should live more righteously. We discard God’s values because they seem to have little bearing on the behavior of his stalwarts.
  • We are unwilling to agree with God’s values because doing so would require us to revise our moral code and change our behavior, sometimes at considerable social and economic risk. Disagreeing with God is safer, more comfortable, and often more pleasurable.

Regardless of our underlying motivation, moral disagreements with God evidence our fallen nature.

Natural Inclination

God embodies moral truth. His values emanate from his character. He created humans in his image, with a flawless nature designed to uphold his moral code.

Humanity became forever corrupt, as measured by God’s standard, when Adam and Eve sinned. We now supplant his moral code with our own, at will, to justify doing whatever we want, whenever we want.

We would like to believe God concurs with our discordant moral values, because we are his handiwork and he loves us unconditionally, but this is untrue.

God’s internal consistency would not allow him to create us in his image and then give us a nature that opposes the moral values emanating from his character.

And the unconditional aspect of God’s love does not mean he endorses the moral values our corrupt nature embraces.

Instead, our natural inclination to subvert God’s moral code evidences our innate rebellion against him.

Moral Relativism

Dismissing God’s moral values leads to moral relativism.

God is inherently good. Therefore, his moral values are singularly good. Abiding by them produces goodness. Moral relativism justifies alternative values that are less than ideal. Abiding by them produces inferior outcomes.

God’s moral values represent absolute truth and, like him, are immutable. To the extent we disagree with them, our moral values are only provisional truths, subject to revision at any time to accommodate our changing feelings or circumstances.

God’s moral values are valid for everyone because he is morally superior to us. To the extent our moral values conflict with his, they are not objectively true for anyone else, since, as fallen creatures, we are morally superior to no one.

Those who disagree with our values, as well as God’s, live by their individual moral codes. Since they are morally equal to us, their values have the same validity as ours. We may consider their moral codes abhorrent, but we lack the objective authority to condemn them.

Moral relativism allows our worst traits to flourish because it can ultimately justify every act of wickedness. It also requires us to passively tolerate retrograde cultures that sanction hatred, bigotry, oppression, misogyny, corruption, and stagnation.

Conversely, adhering to God’s moral code nurtures our virtue by aligning our behavior with his character. Embedding its principles in civil laws produces innovative cultures that promote universal freedom, dignity, equality, justice, and dynamism.

Small God

Disagreements with God about his moral values require us to diminish him and the Bible.

If God exists and is our Creator, he is superior to us and sovereign over us. His moral values take precedence over ours.

If the authors of the Old and New Testaments were divinely inspired when they wrote their original manuscripts and if those documents have been accurately copied and transmitted through the ages, then the Bible faithfully conveys God’s moral values.

To discredit God’s moral code, we must believe that one or both of these things is false. This requires us to disregard the testimony of nature, history, and textual criticism.

Contrarian Dilemmas

Nature bears witness to God’s existence and his role as our Creator.

To argue that God does not exist or is not our Creator, we must explain how energy, matter, time, and space emerged from nothing and formed the universe.

Then we must describe how life spontaneously emerged from these four lifeless elements and began reproducing.

Next, we must account for the fundamental laws of nature—e.g., inertia, gravity, thermodynamics, electromagnetism, and planetary motion—that have kept the universe orderly since its inception.

We must then identify the author of the DNA instructions governing cell behavior.

Finally, we must explain why we are born with an innate sense of right and wrong.

Nature provides sufficient evidence of God’s existence and of his role as our Creator to satisfy those willing to follow him on his terms.

However, no amount of evidence will satisfy those who want to live independently of him.

History attests to the Bible’s divine inspiration.

Old Testament prophecies concerning Babylon, Phoenicia, Assyria, Egypt, Persia, Greece, and Israel—not to mention those concerning the birth, life, death, and resurrection of Jesus—were fulfilled years, decades, or even centuries after they were recorded. Other Old and New Testament prophecies about future events are trending toward fulfillment.

God deliberately included prophecies in the Bible about verifiable historical events throughout human history so their fulfillment would validate its divine inspiration for all generations.

Evidence for the Bible’s textual accuracy far exceeds that of other ancient texts.

Like other works of antiquity, the original Bible manuscripts have long since disintegrated into dust. The Old and New Testaments we read today have been reconstructed from copies of these documents.

We have thousands of partial or complete copies of the Old and New Testament books, including copies of the four Gospels dated within a few decades of the events they describe.

We can be confident that the Bible we read today faithfully reflects the original manuscripts because so many of these copies agree in their text.

There is less support for the textual accuracy of other ancient texts, such as the writings of Plato, Homer, Aristotle, and Socrates, as well as the historical accounts of Herodotus, Thucydides, Xenophon, Julius Caesar, and Tacitus.

Only a few copies of their original manuscripts survive, and the oldest texts are dated centuries or even millennia after these men lived.

Therefore, if we deem the Bible unreliable, we must also question the authenticity of these other ancient texts.

God’s Perspective

Misguided believers dogmatically contend that God hates, as much as they do, those who reject certain tenets of his moral code.

They are wrong. In fact, they are violating God’s third commandment when they invoke his name to justify their personal hatred.

God dislikes the sins that follow our rejection of his moral code, whether in whole or in part, but his love for us is not conditioned on our agreement with his values.

In fact, our acceptance and adherence to God’s moral values are not his top priority.

God’s Priorities

God’s primary concern is our salvation. Above all, he wants us to qualify for heaven so we can spend eternity with him.

Our communion with him is his next priority. He wants us to love him with all our heart, soul, mind, and strength.

God’s third priority is the quality of our relationships. He wants us to treat others as we want to be treated.

Jesus said that if we consistently pursue these priorities, everything else God wants for and from us will eventually fall into place, including our adoption of his moral code.

Eternal Treasure

In Matthew 13:44, Jesus told his disciples a parable that addresses moral disagreements with God. Here it is:

The kingdom of heaven is like treasure hidden in a field. When a man found it, he hid it again, and then in his joy, he sold all he had and bought that field.

Jesus used the phrase “kingdom of heaven” in his teachings to describe God’s reign in our life. This reign is not a function of his conquest or dominance. Instead, it is a matter of our acceptance and consent.

God’s reign in us begins when we accept his gift of salvation through Jesus. After that, it entails our voluntary submission to his authority and our consent to be renewed as he sees fit.

As with other changes he makes in our life, God never demands that we abide by his moral code, even after we ask him to reign in us.

Instead, as we walk in harmony with him, he enlightens us about the superiority of his moral values and instills in us the desire to uphold them as best we can. As this desire intensifies, we increasingly align our morals with his to please both ourselves and him.

Through this parable, Jesus tells us that the benefits of asking God to reign in us—true contentment in this life and eternal bliss in the next—are worth far more than the risks we take, the price we pay, and the control we relinquish when we submit this request.