Draconian Decrees

Some people distrust God because they dislike specific Old Testament laws he instituted and object to the severe penalties he imposed for violating them.

They cannot imagine associating with the strict and punitive moralist portrayed in these decrees.

These folks misread God’s purposes in issuing the Old Testament laws and overlook the grace and mercy he offered to repentant violators.

Moral, Ceremonial, And Civil

On their journey from Egypt to their promised homeland, God gave the Israelites a moral code, commonly known as the Ten Commandments, which instructed them to worship him alone and, in sum, to treat others as they wished to be treated.

Later, God inspired Moses to record ceremonial laws for the Israelites that established celebratory and commemorative feasts and festivals. He conveyed instructions on how they should worship him, purify themselves symbolically, and offer atoning sacrifices for their sins. He also established civil laws for the Israelites, including dietary restrictions, hygiene regulations, and clothing rules, addressing public safety, interpersonal ethics, and social cohesion. Together, these decrees are known as the Mosaic Laws.

The Israelites viewed the Ten Commandments and the Mosaic Laws as a unified, perfection-based system representing God’s will. Breaking them, whether intentionally or accidentally, constituted sin and disqualified a person from heaven unless they repented sincerely and trusted in God’s mercy. Violating a single precept was considered equivalent to breaking them all.

Like us, the Israelites were imperfect people, born with a fallen nature. They all violated the Ten Commandments and the Mosaic Laws at some point, whether in their hearts, minds, or actions. Thus, each was a sinner by God’s standard.

Sacrifices and Penalties

God ordained various sacrifices to atone for certain intentional and unintentional violations of the Mosaic Laws. Acceptable sacrifices ranged from flour, oil, and incense to unblemished bulls, sheep, goats, doves, and pigeons, depending on the lawbreaker’s wealth and the seriousness of the offense.

God also authorized penalties for violating specific laws, ranging from fines, restitution, and imprisonment to exile, flogging, and execution, depending on the offender’s intent and the type, context, and severity of the offense. The death penalty was reserved for deliberate transgressions he deemed most egregious.

Most of us would agree that God was justified in imposing the death penalty for capital offenses such as murder, rape, slave trading, and child sacrifice. We can also understand why he required it for violations such as idolatry, blasphemy, witchcraft, and divination. After all, he insisted that the Israelites worship only him.

However, God mandated capital punishment for infractions that many today consider common behaviors, too anodyne to warrant a severe rebuke, let alone the death penalty. These offenses included breaking the Sabbath, cursing or striking a parent, homosexuality, and adultery.

Mitigating Factors

The Israelites rarely enforced the death penalty for these and other capital offenses, for several reasons.

The Ten Commandments and Mosaic Laws promoted righteousness and discouraged misconduct, establishing cultural norms that reduced the number of incidents warranting capital punishment.

The Israelites also had a rule-based judicial system, staffed by priests and elders, to adjudicate violations of the Mosaic Laws. Defendants had due process rights, and vigilante justice was not permitted.

Convicting someone of a capital offense that carried the death penalty required the testimony of at least two qualified witnesses who had personally observed the alleged violation, an uncommon circumstance.

Courts could also impose a lesser penalty or grant a pardon based on the facts and circumstances of the offense, including whether a lawbreaker confessed to the violation, showed remorse, and sincerely repented.

Here are two examples of God himself granting pardons to people whose capital offenses would have merited the death penalty under the Mosaic Law.

Old Testament Example

David, widely regarded as Israel’s greatest king, was a serious lawbreaker.

As a teenager, he defeated Goliath, a giant Philistine warrior. As king, he organized Israel’s twelve tribes into a nation with Jerusalem as its capital, expanded the country’s borders through conquest, and authored many of the Psalms.

However, amid all this royal success, David, a married man, impregnated a married woman who was not his wife. To cover up this sin, he arranged for her husband, one of his loyal soldiers, to be killed in battle.

Thus, David was personally an adulterer and a murderer by proxy. Under the Mosaic Laws, he deserved the death penalty for these offenses.

However, after one of his trusted advisors confronted him on God’s behalf, David confessed these sins, married the woman, and recommitted himself to living righteously.

In response to his confession, remorse, and repentance, God forgave David and allowed his reign to continue. However, his life was tumultuous thereafter.

New Testament Example

One day, the religious leaders brought an adulterous woman before Jesus and asked whether she should be stoned, as the Mosaic Law required.

He replied that whoever was without sin should cast the first stone. Dumbfounded, her accusers slunk away one by one, keenly aware of their own sinfulness.

After the last person departed, Jesus asked the woman whether anyone had formally convicted her of adultery. Rather than refuting the premise of his question by asserting her innocence, she replied that no one had, implicitly affirming her guilt.

Jesus told her to go and sin no more, effectively forgiving her without downplaying the seriousness of her sin.

Applicability Today

Are spiritually reborn believers today subject to the Ten Commandments and the Mosaic Laws?

The Ten Commandments apply to us in full except for the activity restriction in the fourth commandment, which concerns keeping the Sabbath. Jesus effectively rescinded this prohibition by healing people multiple times on that holy day. However, the universal principles of human dignity and equality inherent in this commandment remain applicable.

The ceremonial laws and atoning sacrifices God instituted in the Old Testament are inoperative for spiritually reborn believers. The death of Jesus paid the penalty for all our sins—past, present, and future; egregious and innocuous; willful and unintentional. His sacrifice gave us direct access to God at any time, just as we are, eliminating the need for us to perform these rituals or for an intercessor to do so on our behalf.

The civil laws God prescribed in the Old Testament do not apply to spiritually reborn believers today because we are not citizens of ancient Israel.

However, the community values embedded in specific laws, such as caring for the vulnerable, sharing our resources with people in need, and loving our neighbors, remain generally operative for us. Legal principles in some decrees, such as restorative justice, equality before the law, the presumption of innocence, and the right to confront one’s accusers, still inform judicial systems in many countries today.

The New Testament restates the Old Testament laws and commandments on sexual ethics but does not reaffirm the penalties for violating them. Instead, it elevates grace, mercy, forgiveness, and redemption over punishment.

Purposes Beyond Conduct

The Ten Commandments and Mosaic Laws did more than regulate the Israelites’ personal behavior.

They comprised the legal framework for the theocracy the Israelites established in their promised homeland.

They distinguished the monotheistic Israelites from their polytheistic pagan neighbors, morally and culturally, and reinforced their identity as God’s chosen people.

These decrees also served several theological functions.

  • The laws and commandments formalized God’s authority over the Israelites and constantly reminded them of his sovereignty.
  • They revealed what God considers righteous and holy, as well as what he detests.
  • The thoroughness of the laws and the exacting specificity of the atoning sacrifices required the Israelites to approach God on his terms, with humility, reverence, and intentionality. He was not to be treated casually or obeyed nonchalantly.
  • The penalties God authorized for violating the laws and commandments revealed, from his perspective, the seriousness of sin.
  • The hierarchy of punishments revealed which sins he deemed most egregious and, inversely, the personal behaviors and societal norms he valued most.
  • The atoning sacrifices revealed God’s mercy, while the penalties for carelessly executing them underscored his justice.
  • The comprehensiveness of the laws and commandments made it clear to the Israelites that their personal performance would never qualify them for heaven; they would have to trust in God’s mercy for salvation.

Judging God

Those who disparage God because they dislike the Mosaic Laws are essentially claiming that their moral values and ethical judgments transcend his.

If that were true, they would be God, not him.

These folks need to remember that God is perfect. His righteousness exceeds ours. His sense of fairness is more acute than ours. His understanding of what is truly just is more accurate than ours. When he inspired Moses to record the laws and penalties, he cared more about their equity than we ever could.

Those who deem God petty and heartless because they consider his Old Testament laws and punishments unduly harsh forget that he is supremely merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love and faithfulness. His justice comes to the fore only after sinners fail to respond to his offer of redemption and remain unrepentant.

In some cases, God’s penalties limited punishment, ensuring proportionality to the offense, preventing cycles of escalating vengeance, and preserving the dignity of the violators. Examples include an eye for an eye, not the exenteration of two eyes in retribution for the loss of one; a maximum of forty lashes, precluding the vindictive administration of a higher, more torturous count.

Some argue that God is morally inconsistent because spiritually reborn believers are not required to abide by the civil laws he mandated for the Israelites. His moral values have never changed, but the demographics of his followers have evolved.

The Israelites were familial citizens of a single nation with a unique culture, a theocracy organized around God’s moral values where personal sins, including lapses in proper worship, carried civil penalties. Today, spiritually reborn believers from a range of ethnicities live worldwide in countries with distinctive cultures, diverse belief systems, and different forms of government. We are now subject to local laws and penalties enacted by secular legislative bodies that are not bound by God’s immutable moral values.

The Mosaic Laws regulated certain practices that God condemns elsewhere in the Bible, such as polygamy and chattel slavery. These civil laws do not mean that he approved of these activities when conducted by the Israelites, but hypocritically condemned them when practiced by other people groups. His moral laws have always applied equally to everyone. He still deemed these practices sinful, even when conducted by the Israelites.

These particular civil laws reflect God’s awareness that the Israelites would engage in these immoral activities despite his prohibition and that regulations were necessary to protect those who would suffer as a result. In this regard, God acted like state legislators today who enact civil laws regulating activities they personally disdain, but that their constituents endorse, such as cannabis sales and online gambling.

Some critics contend that the thorniest Mosaic Laws can be disregarded because someone other than Moses wrote them and they were not divinely inspired.

These folks need to convince Jesus otherwise.

He vouched for the Old Testament’s divine inspiration and frequently discussed the Mosaic Laws without repudiating their origin or authority.

New Testament Standard

Jesus fully complied with the Ten Commandments and the Mosaic Laws while living a sinless life on earth, though he challenged, reinterpreted, and ignored certain overreaching applications of the latter that the Pharisees enforced.

He said spiritually reborn believers would fulfill the laws and commandments if we love God with all our heart, soul, mind, and strength and treat others as we would like to be treated.

Read More

Disregarding God’s values leads to moral relativism, which can ultimately justify all sorts of evil. Learn more here.

Another page on this website offers further insights into the Ten Commandments.